Album Review: The Menzingers – “Rented World”

Editor Rating:
  User's Rating:

In 2011, The Menzingers released “On The Impossible Past” (an album that pretty much everyone in the world agrees is the best thing ever) so expectations were sky-high for the Philadelphia band’s follow up. “Rented World” meets those expectations. It is 12 songs of biting emotional punk rock, but this time around, The Menzingers ramped up the musicianship and made an album that is at times quieter and more fragile than anything the band has ever released, and at other times so enormous that it’s just begging to be played in front of thousands of people.

The album kicks off with “I Don’t Wan’t To Be An Asshole Anymore”, the kind of scrappy pop-punk song The Menzingers are known for. Lyrically this song is full of the kind of poetry we heard a lot of on On The Impossible Past. Lines like “Last Friday night I wasn’t me/ I was a still -life trapped in eternity/ I was the focal point out of focus, out of ink” demonstrate songwriter Greg Barnett’s unique brand of lyricism. The sing along chorus is just begging to be played at the band’s intense live show.

“Rented World” sees The Menzingers expanding their sound, starting from the second song on the album, and the first song we hear written by the band’s other songwriter, Tom May.  “Bad Things” starts from a quiet dreamy verse, before exploding into a huge grunge-influenced pre-chorus, and then back to pop-punk for one of the catchiest choruses on the album. The way The Menzingers successfully mix genres, without compromising the core sound of the band, is perhaps the greatest triumph of “Rented World”, making the album sound huge all throughout.

Other notable tracks on the album include “Transient Love” a 5 minute mid-tempo rocker which builds around a catchy drumbeat delivered by Joe Godino, with ambient guitars and a quiet, heartfelt chorus. “Nothing Feels Good Anymore” displays the kind of lyrical ability we’ve come to expect from Greg Barnett. The storytelling lyrics in the verses (“Baby baby buzz me in/ I ring your intercom and say/ But you just poke your head through a curtain/and my heart’s on the floor/nothing feels good anymore”) explode into one of the best choruses on the whole album.

The album closes with “When You Died” a quiet acoustic song where Barnett asks simple questions, but ones which we all ask when we lose a loved one: “Where do people go when they die?/How do you keep them alive?/ How do you make nothing like this will ever happen again?”

“Rented World” shows The Menzingers taking a leap forward musically, and delivering the same kind of emotional lyrics that we loved on “On The Impossible Past”. Is this album better than OTIP? Maybe. Maybe not. People are inevitably going to try to rank the two and make comparisons and contrasts, but at the end of the day, “Rented World” gives us 12 more great songs by a band who is poised to become one of the biggest in our scene, and that can only be a good thing.

5/5 Stars

Add The Menzingers to My Radar   Add to My Radar


  1. mitchattitude
    mitchattitude4/27/2014 11:43 AM | Permalink

    it’s their best album to date!

  2. iamhuman666
    iamhuman6665/5/2014 7:59 PM | Permalink

    Five fucking huge red white and blue stars for these Americans. I was a little freaked out when I heard the title for the first song on the record. I guess I was afraid they were going to go… well a little less… intelligent than the older shit. I still feel american when I hear it though, and fuck no is this shit not intelligent (think about that double negative for a second, holy shit). They are fucking smart, that’s what I’m trying to say. Haha. Great record, yet again!!!!

  3. The Menzingers announce UK & Europe tour dates with The Holy Mess, Smith Street Band5/12/2014 8:04 PM | Permalink

    […] Rented World […]

  4. ultramerican
    Ultramerican6/27/2014 4:06 PM | Permalink

    I thought the same thing a second ago. I get hints of melodies which take my mind to “Crash Love”.

    To everyone comparing this to OTIP, you’re the worst kind of music fans. You’re probably the same type of people who argue whether “Blue’ or “Pinkerton” are Weezer’s best album. I found the Menzingers this year, and with no frame of reference, backtracked and listened to OTIP. It sounds so immature compared to Rented World. It’s not bad, it’s just nowhere near as mature in songwriting or production. Both are great albums, just appreciate the tracks you like on each.

  5. dylstew
    dylstew7/2/2014 9:22 AM | Permalink

    This album really disappoints me, it’s easily their worst album.
    It’s still an okay album though. I really like In Remission and The Talk, and The Rodent’s okay. Those are the standout tracks to me.

  6. leonardmcdaniel
    LeonardMcDaniel6/15/2015 11:54 PM | Permalink

    u rock buddy

  7. Nicholas Mullenax6/19/2015 2:30 AM | Permalink

    i am your fan

  8. DallasYoun7/2/2015 10:50 PM | Permalink

    awesome work

  9. AlverdRex10/3/2015 5:17 AM | Permalink


  10. ericlimberlet9/27/2016 8:32 AM | Permalink


Leave A Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.