10 Cover Songs Gone Wrong

10 Cover Songs Gone Wrong

Let’s face it, some cover songs were just not meant to be. The kind of cover that makes you sigh and say, “This song probably probably shouldn’t have happened.” And that’s okay- it’s not easy living up to the musical standards of often-covered punk greats like NOFX or Misfits. Even well-regarded bands like Rancid or Me First and The Gimme Gimmes are capable of a bad cover every now and then.

We’ve highlighted some of the worst, goofiest, out-of-place, and most entertaining covers gone wrong for your enjoyment/naseau. Check out the (nowhere near comprehensive) list right here.

10. Of Montreal – Where Eagles Dare (Misfits)

If you’re an indie synth pop band and you want to cover a punk song to be edgy, okay fine, nobody’s going to stop you. But PLEASE don’t do it to the Misfits.

9. Rancid– Don’t Call Me White (NOFX)

Like most punk fans, I can (try to) enjoy Rancid bassist Matt Freeman’s voice every once in a while…but definitely not this time. I’m going to have to agree with the apt analysis of a Youtube commentator here: I can’t help thinking that Freeman sounds like an Angry Kermit the Frog.

8. Metallica – 53rd and 3rd (Ramones)

Proof that most tracks that come off of tribute albums usually suck.

7. Chumbawamba – Bankrobber (The Clash)

Has anybody actually heard a good a capella punk song?

6. Dwight Yoakam – Train In Vain (The Clash)

Bands like Social Distortion showed us that country and punk actually can mix well. Covers like this one remind us that they should generally keep their distance.

5. Furillo – Final Coutndown (Europe)

Ska punk covers of 80’s songs are usually bad enough, but they got a whole lot worse when Furillo decided to cover the absolute worst song of the decade:

4. Emilie Simon – I Wanna Be Your Dog (Iggy Pop & The Stooges)

I wonder who told all of these electro-pop bands that it was a good idea to cover bands like The Stooges.

3. Nouvelle Vague – To Drunk To F*ck (Dead Kennedys)

Maybe this one’s funny because of all the “irony.” But probably not.

2. Kylie Minogue – Should I Stay Or Should I Go (The Clash)

Anybody want to guess how many people in the audience actually know the original song?

1. Amy Whinehouse – A Message To You Rudy (The Specials)

Enough said.


Discover more from Dying Scene

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *