To the omniscient hipster that said punk is dead, and all his brethren.
I was looking at guitars when we first met. It makes sense. I was in a music store and you worked there as a salesman. You seemed friendly enough with your flat cap, thick rimmed glasses, and penchant for self deprecation (as you reminded me several times, the fact that you’re Jewish is somehow inherently funny). You did everything a salesman should do, even going so far to emasculate yourself for the sake of my ego. Oh yes, I remember how you got down on one knee, mightily raising devil horns to my display of four chugging power chords. I didn’t buy anything that day, because like most days, I didn’t have any money. But I didn’t leave empty handed, I had the memory of your bearded facade doing a looping I’m-not-worthy, like some inane GIF from the Netscape days.
When I got a job at the record store across from where you worked, I figured there would be some chance meetings. Perhaps you would wander by one day, and I’d be able to see you from the storefront window, inhaling a cigarette (American Spirit, no doubt). I would of course use this time to switch my iPod over to the most impressively inaccessible noise rock Pitchfork can recommend. Maybe you’d walk in casually and hear how great my taste is, nodding silent approval because spoken approval is for sheeple.
Reality decided to take a different route, one where cordial greetings are exchanged and I get chided for playing The Black Keys, which apparently isn’t cool anymore. We chatted back and forth about music and the weather, eventually arriving at the arena of my own tastes. To my surprise, my admission to liking punk rock wasn’t met with disdain, skepticism, or even the fabled admiration. No, instead I got a lecture on how great The Sonics were.
In case you didn’t know, The Sonics were a garage rock band from the Northwest United States active in the sixties. Now, I understand garage rock heavily influenced the sound of punk rock. I get that. But have we seriously reached the point of cultural one-upsmanship that we have gone beyond claiming to have liked it first, to the point that we now claim to like it before it existed?
But you know what, I’m probably wrong. Your flannel clearly distinguishes you as a man of great critical capacity. I can accept a lot of things. You probably know a lot of worthy indie rock bands, and yeah, The Black Keys might pale in comparison to other blues rock bands, and from what you say The Sonics sound pretty great.
I can accept all of that, but one thing you said remains burned into my mind.
“All modern punk sucks.”
I laughed it off when I first heard it, perhaps as a subconscious way to avoid conflict. But the more I think about it, the more it burns.
Ignorance is acceptable, I would’ve taken “I don’t know any modern punk bands” or “I haven’t heard any that I’ve liked.” But that’s not what you said, you spoke with an arrogant absolute that suggests you’re either omniscient or an uninformed elitist. And from what I’ve heard, I’m leaning towards the latter. Of course, if I’m wrong, I bow to your all seeing eye.
But I’m going to take a leap of faith and assume you’re a mortal, with all the fallacies that implies. And I’m going to call you out, Music Store Hipster– You’re wrong.
No one’s denying that punk was great in the 70’s, or as you claim, even better in the 60’s. But it’s not a one or the other situation. Both can be great, and the fact of the matter is that both are great. But I’m willing to argue its gotten better.
We’ve gotten to a point where anyone can record from home with a computer and a microphone and distribute over the internet for little to no cost. This is the height of musical freedom. Labels aren’t a deciding factor whether you get heard or not. You are the only factor. With that freedom comes creative liberty. Pure art, unfiltered by the demands of consumerism is available at your fingertips. A singular artistic voice, any singular artistic voice can be heard. We can say ‘fuck you’ to every convention, opinion, and tradition currently known to man; then upload it with the same middle finger we used to declare it. Every sub-genre is being reinvented and subverted on a daily basis, formulas are being broken down, lines are being crossed. And it’s happening in the punk community. It’s happening in every community.
Can you disregard an entire movement based on what you heard on the radio? Can you claim to hate what you’ve based on blind elitism alone? This is punk rock’s brightest day yet. It’s the day that we’re uncensored and technologically capable.
So, to the hipster that told me modern punk sucks?
Fuck you.
Discover more from Dying Scene
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.