DS Editorial: Before They Sold Out

DS Editorial: Before They Sold Out

Dying Scene writers aren’t much different than you Dying Scene readers.  Yeah, we have news writing superpowers, but ultimately we are just super fans of the punk genre like the rest of you.  And like the rest of you we have our own individual thoughts and opinions and sometimes we just got to get stuff […]

Dying Scene writers aren’t much different than you Dying Scene readers.  Yeah, we have news writing superpowers, but ultimately we are just super fans of the punk genre like the rest of you.  And like the rest of you we have our own individual thoughts and opinions and sometimes we just got to get stuff off our chest. Editorial style. So with that in mind, we’d like to remind all of our handsomely toned and intelligent readers that the views expressed in these articles are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect those of the entire Dying Scene staff.

Working at a small town record store, I had the opportunity to meet throngs of people who shared little musical interests with me. Now usually this wouldn’t phase me, but goddamn it, I was working in a record store. Music was our common factor, bringing us together in the name of sonic discovery and commerce. But to my chagrin, the hipsters ruled my town with an iron, elitist fist. And when I wasn’t feigning affection for the latest Fleet Foxes record, I was inevitably tasked with defending my own preferences. It seemed that when I politely responded to queries regarding my musical interests (punk), the only encountered answer was “Oh, like The Catheters?”

No, not like The Catheters.

It’s funny, with all the talk of how punk is commercialized, not many people are really familiar with the genre. I readily admit my horizons aren’t very broad. When I say I listen to punk I mean for people to read between the lines and silently insert the word ‘exclusively.’ But for all my failings as a well versed music listener, I am at the very least aware of what’s happening in different scenes. I know the hipsters like Bon Iver. Metalheads hate metalcore. Casual listeners are into Adele. I’m not oblivious. But how many non-punk enthusiasts do you know that can name even some of the bands that populate our top tier of accessible music? I’m not talking about Green Day, Rise Against, or Blink-182 either; those bands are so big that they crossover into mainstream music without the help or hindrance of the punk label. No, I’m talking about the bands everyone knows in the scene. Bands like No Trigger, Hot Water Music, or Banner Pilot. Even the music we tend to condescendingly dismiss as entry level is fairly unheard of outside our own kind. Pennywise and Bad Religion elicit more blank stares than conversation. Instead, we get The Catheters.

So, needless to say, I had to turn to my fellow employees for musical discussion. I found that there was at least one guy who liked Leftover Crack, and while that wasn’t exactly what I wanted, I wondered if it was perhaps what I needed. On a warm and sunny summer afternoon I was hanging out after my shift for no real reason but to talk with someone who shared some of my interests. Idly, my fingers spidered up and down through alphabetized CD spines.

There’s a phrase, a combination of words every punk hears at some point or the other. So ubiquitous in punk rock that they almost define it. I was about to hear these words uttered with the casual conviction they are so often delivered.

My fingers perched on the G’s, my eyes rested on a familiar band name. Uncontrollably, perhaps inevitably, the conversation turned to Green Day. I knew the words before he said them, I could have spoken them in measured unison, perhaps even harmonizing them at this point.

“I liked them, before they sold out.”

It wasn’t until this moment that I truly considered those words, and that’s when I came to the conclusion that they were as meaningless as any cliche. This wasn’t communication, this wasn’t an exchange of ideas. This was a recycled opinion reappropriated as conversation. Like a virus, it spread and became the de facto critical analysis of an entire catalog of work. So pervasive now, that teenagers who have never listened to Green Day are adopting it as their own creed and code. I liked Dookie and their early stuff, but their later stuff just got too mainstream. This is where critical evaluation ceases to be critical, and becomes ritual.

With all its vagaries and sinister imagery, selling out is a cornerstone of punk culture. For a scene and genre so insistent on authenticity, ‘sell out’ and its derivatives are as much a declaration of righteous responsibility as it is petty finger pointing. There are definite, valid criticisms of a band like Green Day. But using a catch-all phrase like ‘selling out’, isn’t one.

The hardest part of earnestly applying the sell out label is that it’s a reaction to unknowable intentions. Bands like Against Me!, Anti-Flag, and Green Day all made the jump to the majors; news of which seems to never be taken well. But it also represents the core of the ‘sell out’ problem: Us vs. Them. Studded jackets, mohawks, inaccessible music; we like to romanticize it all with talk of self expression, all the while extracting the personal element that drives the rebellion. There’s a need to separate ourselves from the mainstream, reject its culture and build our own. The shining light of punk rock is built on the do-it-yourself principal. It’s art for the sake of art. You could say punk is about creating music for an audience of one. The fact that there’s a world of punk fans is almost incidental; the music is made for the sake of the artist. So, equating the move to a major label with artistic hackery is not exactly a leap of logic. But, it does lack perspective. Henry Rollins once said, “Selling out is when you make the record you’re told to make, instead of the one you want to make,” succinctly defining it in plain-spoken English. But it raises the question: can we ever know for certain that a band has sold out?

As much as we fight it, artists have to make money to be able to continue producing. They need walls to surround them, food to eat, and gas in their tanks to tour. But this is where the problem of intentions rears it’s ugly head. We don’t think about a band having to eat and make a living. For some reason, we find it hard to imagine our same day-to-day troubles being a shared experience with the musicians we hold in such high esteem. The very nature of the rock star, the target of much of the punk ethos, is still very much here to stay, albeit in a different form. Punk rockers are getting burned at the digital stake, for both real and perceived transgressions because we hold them up to ideals that they never get to choose. We decide their morality, we decide when they’ve done wrong.

Against Me!’s Tom Gabel may have been an anarchist at one point, but it was the scene that held him to the statements he made a decade ago. It was almost as if the punk scene forced him into the role of an archetype, and it became our perception of his identity. When Against Me! signed to Sire, there was inevitably outrage. And there was a permeable feeling that this isn’t what we wanted for him. When he broke from the mold, frustration mounted. As he redefined himself on his own terms, the audience felt betrayed. This is where our own sense of ethics become overbearing; more than ever, art is at the mercy of scene politics.  As if a challenge to inherent punkness is the pinnacle of all dismissals.

Can we be better?

Can we judge music, and not equate it with labels or perceived punkness?

We have a chance to be more rational. We have a chance to be better music listeners. If we can let go of this archaic concept, we can move forward without self righteousness determining our tastes. “Before they sold out,” can be a laughably uninformed thing of the past.

I know we can be better.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Album Review: MxPx – “Plans Within Plans”

Album Review: MxPx – “Plans Within Plans”

Being a punk band with a virtually uninterrupted twenty-year shelf life used to be a rare occurrence. The Ramones did it, the Clash and Sex Pistols and Buzzcocks couldn’t (in their original incarnations, anyway). In fact, few others could pull it off until Bad Religion, Social Distortion and NOFX came around. Then the rise of […]

Being a punk band with a virtually uninterrupted twenty-year shelf life used to be a rare occurrence. The Ramones did it, the Clash and Sex Pistols and Buzzcocks couldn’t (in their original incarnations, anyway). In fact, few others could pull it off until Bad Religion, Social Distortion and NOFX came around.

Then the rise of “mainstream punk” came along in the 1990s. Suddenly, the list of bands celebrating twenty year anniversaries has increased exponentially. Twenty years used to seem like an eternity; now it seems like a long weekend. For some perspective, Bad Religion’s Generator and NOFX’s Whte Trash, Two Heebs and a Bean were released twenty years ago, but still seem as timely and relevant as ever. Contrast that with twenty years prior (1972 for you non-math punks) when the hot releases of the day included Donny Osmond’s “Puppy Love,” T. Rex’s “Bang A Gong” and Seals & Croft’s “Summer Breeze.” As a teenager in 1992, I distinctly remember each of those sounding not just old, but prehistoric.

2012 finds MxPx celebrating their twentieth anniversary with, among other things, a brand new album, Plans Within Plans, that features the Bremerton, Washintgon, three-piece sounding just as vital as ever. Time has changed some things; the band will no longer tour as the original three-piece (stupid day jobs!), and the lyrics have matured from the confusions of a teenage punk to anthems of the working class and the nostalgia that comes with being a thirty-something looking back over the years.

Album opener “Aces Up” emphatically announces MxPx’s return to the game and immediately reveals their relevance. It’s as intense as anything in their catalog and it’s 95% of a good song. I say 95% because the electronic drum fill injects a little too much “pop” in the pop-punk mix. Think Good Charlotte. “Screw Loose” gets things back on track in classic three-chord street punk style, and totally calls for a video featuring skateboards. Lots and lots of skateboards. Or an overdub of Green Day’s “Basket Case” video. But I digress.

Plans Within Plans is chock-full of tracks that stay true to the youthful energy that is inherent in good pop-punk music while telling stories that prove that it is possible to “grow up” and still be a punk. “The Times” is a good example; a bass-heavy, with ‘fuck authority’ overtones that still finds a place for positivity and optimism: “Every day is better/Than the one before.” “Best Of Times” is a more mid-tempo pop punk track that finds Herrera in a particularly reflective mood, simultaneously coming across as nostalgic of the past and hopeful of the future: “We’re growing up and all that it takes/Is looking forward to better days… I love life now / but those were the best of times.”

A few of the other highlights are “Nothing Left” and “Inside Out” – reminiscent of vintage (read as: good) No Use For A Name. “Nothing’s Gonna Change” has a march quality to it, and the lead riff is on the darker, minor chordy side, which matches the lyrical direction of this particular look in the proverbial mirror. “Far Away” and “In The Past” feature the guitar stylings of Stephen Egerton from the legendary Descendents (Egerton also mixed and mastered the album).

While staying incredibly true to the band’s pop-punk roots, Plans Within Plans is MxPx’s most grown-up work to date. If you grew up with them figuratively in the early-mid 90s (and perhaps drifted away from them after they slowly went the way of the buffalo), this album will fit very nicely into your regular rotation, feeling very relatable in the process. Plus, it won’t leave you feeling incredibly old for singing along to songs about bad hair days and TV anymore!

4.25/5

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Watch: Joey Cape interviewed about upcoming streaming internet concert from his living room

Watch: Joey Cape interviewed about upcoming streaming internet concert from his living room

Lagwagon frontman and everyone’s favorite acoustic troubadour Joey Cape is playing a live streaming internet concert from his living room this Saturday night (March 31st). Click here for more information on how to check it out. Hard-hitting, cute-as-a-button British reporter Pepsi recently interrogated the Caper about the event. Click here to watch her cut through […]

Lagwagon frontman and everyone’s favorite acoustic troubadour Joey Cape is playing a live streaming internet concert from his living room this Saturday night (March 31st). Click here for more information on how to check it out.

Hard-hitting, cute-as-a-button British reporter Pepsi recently interrogated the Caper about the event. Click here to watch her cut through the BS and get you all the info you need to know.

Joey Cape has been working on a full-length follow-up to his 2004 collaboration with NUFAN frontman Tony Sly. Stay tuned for details. [Read more…]

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Streaming Audio: El Hefe (NOFX) remixes Margate’s “Rock N Roll Reserve”

Streaming Audio: El Hefe (NOFX) remixes Margate’s “Rock N Roll Reserve”

As you may recall, NOFX lead guitarist Aaron “El Hefe” Abeyta and his wife Jennifer have started their own record label, Cyber Tracks, and he has signed LA pop-punks Margate to be the first band on their label. Margate are currently hard at work on a new full length album. El Hefe is at the […]

As you may recall, NOFX lead guitarist Aaron “El Hefe” Abeyta and his wife Jennifer have started their own record label, Cyber Tracks, and he has signed LA pop-punks Margate to be the first band on their label.

Margate are currently hard at work on a new full length album. El Hefe is at the helm of the new recording, and has also taken the time to remix the title track from Margate’s “Rock N Roll Reserve EP,” released last year on their own Room 57 Records. Hefe also contributed backing vocals and lead guitar duties to the remix. Check it out here.

While you’re at it, click here to check out Margate’s tour dates for the next few months.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New Video: D-Cent Jerks – “Dead And Buried”

New Video: D-Cent Jerks – “Dead And Buried”

Seven-piece Puerto Rican punk outfit D-Cent Jerks have released a new video for the track “Dead And Buried.” Check it out here, courtesy of our friends at PunkVideosRock.com. As a point of reference, think of them as a more straight-up punk version of Voodoo Glow Skulls, complete with a three-piece horn section. Good stuff. D-Cent […]

Seven-piece Puerto Rican punk outfit D-Cent Jerks have released a new video for the track “Dead And Buried.” Check it out here, courtesy of our friends at PunkVideosRock.com.

As a point of reference, think of them as a more straight-up punk version of Voodoo Glow Skulls, complete with a three-piece horn section. Good stuff.

D-Cent Jerks’ last album was their self-titled, self-released 2011 EP. [Read more…]

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tour: MxPx announce “20th Anniversary” tour dates

Tour: MxPx announce “20th Anniversary” tour dates

Long-running Bremerton, WA, pop-punk key holders MxPx have announced preliminary dates for a tour celebrating the band’s twentieth anniversary. The dates (which will feature the original three-piece lineup rather than the MxPx All-Star rotating lineup) also serve to support the band’s soon-to-be-releasaed ninth studio album, “Plans Within Plans.” Click here to check out the dates. […]

Long-running Bremerton, WA, pop-punk key holders MxPx have announced preliminary dates for a tour celebrating the band’s twentieth anniversary. The dates (which will feature the original three-piece lineup rather than the MxPx All-Star rotating lineup) also serve to support the band’s soon-to-be-releasaed ninth studio album, “Plans Within Plans.”

Click here to check out the dates. All dates are west coast for now, but we’ll keep you posted if anything changes. While you’re waiting, click here to watch MxPx frontman Mike Herrera perform “Aces Up” from the new album from the latest installment of Dying Scene’s exclusive Acoustic Session.

“Plans Within Plans” is due out next Tuesday on MRI/Rock City Recording Company. [Read more…]

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Al Barr (Dropkick Murphys) issues apology for using homophobic slur

Al Barr (Dropkick Murphys) issues apology for using homophobic slur

Earlier today, Dropkick Murphys‘ Al Barr caught some internet heat when he used the word “f*ggot” in a promo video (which has since been taken off Vimeo). He issued an apology via Facebook, which you can read below: hey everybody – al barr here – i just wanted to address the negative comment that i […]

Earlier today, Dropkick Murphys‘ Al Barr caught some internet heat when he used the word “f*ggot” in a promo video (which has since been taken off Vimeo). He issued an apology via Facebook, which you can read below:

hey everybody –

al barr here – i just wanted to address the negative comment that i made. first off, i’d like to apologize for using the term that i did. by no means did i intend for it to cause any hurt or harm, i now fully realize how insensitive it was.

having grown up within a very diverse punk scene, i have many gay friends. i would never want to hurt anyone’s feelings with my comments.

i did not mean anything by this and now understand it is a word that i should not have used and will not use in the future. please accept my sincere apologies.

my band and i are any anything but homophobic and our 16 year track record proves that we stand up for human rights and fight against injustices towards all people.

thanks for your time and support, and again, please accept my sincere apologies.

The band recently released “Going Out In Style – Fenway Edition” via their own Born and Bred Records.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Video: Touche Amore perform new song live

Video: Touche Amore perform new song live

Touche Amore recently played a show in the Netherlands, and at that show they played a brand new, untitled song, which is apparently appearing on the band’s upcoming album. You can check the video out here. The band last released “Parting the Sea Between Brightness and Me” June 7th on Deathwish Inc. We’ll keep you […]

Touche Amore recently played a show in the Netherlands, and at that show they played a brand new, untitled song, which is apparently appearing on the band’s upcoming album.

You can check the video out here.

The band last released “Parting the Sea Between Brightness and Me” June 7th on Deathwish Inc. We’ll keep you posted as more details on their upcoming album surface.

[Read more…]

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Video: The Sidekicks perform acoustic cover of The Menzingers’ song “Good Things”

Video: The Sidekicks perform acoustic cover of The Menzingers’ song “Good Things”

Ohio pop-punk/indie rock act, The Sidekicks, recently performed an acoustic cover of The Menzingers‘ song, “Good Things.” You can watch the performance here. The Sidekicks last released “Awkward Breeds” in February on Red Scare Industries. Click here to check out a full list of dates and locations for the tour they are currently on, with The Menzingers, […]

Ohio pop-punk/indie rock act, The Sidekicks, recently performed an acoustic cover of The Menzingers‘ song, “Good Things.”

You can watch the performance here.

The Sidekicks last released “Awkward Breeds” in February on Red Scare Industries. Click here to check out a full list of dates and locations for the tour they are currently on, with The Menzingers, and Cheap Girls.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tour: Silverstein announce Australian tour w/ Skyway

Tour: Silverstein announce Australian tour w/ Skyway

Silverstein have announced they will be hitting the road for an Australian tour with support from Skyway, in June. You can check out a full list of dates and locations for this tour here. The band’s most recent release, “Short Songs,” dropped last month on Hopeless Records.

Silverstein have announced they will be hitting the road for an Australian tour with support from Skyway, in June.

You can check out a full list of dates and locations for this tour here.

The band’s most recent release, “Short Songs,” dropped last month on Hopeless Records. [Read more…]

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *