
Punk rock has been around long enough to hold within its musical boundaries a slew of albums considered both classic and essential. We here at Dying Scene love and appreciate these classic albums, but every once and a while we have the urge to challenge what the community has deemed sacred. Every Saturday, two Dying Scene writers will square off head-to-head and either attack or defend one of these so-called classics. Up for slaughter today is the Ramones‘ self-titled. Does the 1976 classic hold up today? You be the judge. Dustin Gates will be defending and Maggie Hobbs will be attacking.
The Defense
Simply put: Ramones is a classic album because it doesn’t pretend to be anything that it’s not. In a time when rock and roll music was all about living the glamorous rock star lifestyle (KISS), or hobbits and stealing licks from Robert Johnson (Led Zeppelin), or singing the praises of Ayn Rand (Rush), the whole of rock music was getting too grand scale for itself to handle. No one could relate to the music unless they were either a rock star themselves, or just did a lot of drugs and read a lot of Ayn Rand (and who has the time for that?). What rock music needed was a swift kick of humility. That’s when the Ramones stepped in and gave rock and roll back to the disaffected youth.
Much like Elvis in the 50’s and the Beatles in the 60’s, there was an element of rebellion to this fast music that drew in the young crowds of the 1970’s… kids could relate to the lyrical simplicity of love songs like “I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend” and “Listen to My Heart” just as much as they could connect to the anger in songs such as “I Don’t Wanna Walk Around With You” and “Loudmouth”. Primary lyricist Dee Dee Ramone wasn’t one to use any arousing metaphors or mind-blowing analogies; his writing technique mostly consists of the old blues style of song writing of repeating lines and verses several times. Whether this was done out of laziness or as a tribute to his favorite artists of the past, Dee Dee’s lyrics of alienation and (seemingly) unrequited love not only spoke volumes to the youth of the 70’s, but continue to be relatable to the youth of today.
Unlike their predecessors in the previous decades, however, there’s a timeless danger to the music of the Ramones. The four “brothers” from Queens, NY weren’t only singing about wanting to hold a girl’s hand, or not wanting people to step on their new shoes: two things which are quite tame by today’s standards. No, instead the songs on Ramones are about sniffing brand name glue as a means of getting a cheap high (“Now I Wanna Sniff Some Glue”), wanting to beat people down with baseball bats (“Beat on the Brat”), and the life of living as a male prostitute (53rd and 3rd). The Ramones might not be the only musicians to ever come from broken lifestyles, but not many could make that claim while burying their life stories underneath bubblegum pop melodies and simple chord progressions.
It’s ironic that Ramones is a classic and revolutionary album due to its lack of progression. There’s no razzle dazzle to make the tracks sound pretty; there are no virtuoso attempts at guitar solos to “wow” listeners; there are no Dylan or Lennon-esque lyrics to make people really sit down and think; there’s not even a professional vocalist fronting the band: Joey Ramone was originally the band’s drummer and only moved to vocals because Dee Dee Ramone’s voice couldn’t take it. Even proto-punk albums like Raw Power have some flashy guitar work to them, but the Ramones truly stripped rock music down to its bare minimum for their debut. It’s a fine rock and roll album that can speak to the youth of any generation, even after nearly forty years since its release. If you ask me, any album that can do that deserves the praise and hype, within the punk community or otherwise.
The Attack
When The Ramones broke out into the music scene back in 1976, they likely had no idea how big punk rock would be someday. Instead, they did what the bored and angry do best: be loud, obnoxious, and try to have a good time.
While The Ramones did stand out from their musical contemporaries, with the music scene at the time being filled to the brim with disco, glam rock, and psychedelic drugs, I have an issue with their 1976 self-titled debut album being heralded as the album which defined a genre. First of all, it doesn’t give much credit to bands like The New York Dolls who formed five years before The Ramones’ self-titled, and secondly, it puts too much emphasis on an album which, frankly, isn’t that great.
I know, I know, punk rock was never about the guitar solos and the ability to play more than three chords; however, compared to other punk rock albums of that era such as The Sex Pistols’ “Never Mind The Bollocks, Here’s The Sex Pistols,” and The Clash’s 1977 debut, it is rather boring. There is little to distinguish any of the tracks: it all seems like one twenty-eight minute song. The lyrics are about as deep as a disco ball, and it lacks the attitude that became so characteristic of the punk rock movement. Joey Ramone’s vocal range makes Rancid’s Tim Armstrong sound like a classically trained tenor in comparison and he sounds like he got lessons in human emotion from Mitt Romney. In the end, The Ramones’ self-titled album sounds more like it was written from the viewpoint of human apathy, while other punk rock albums were being written out of anger.
“Beat On The Brat” is a perfect example of how The Ramones needed a crash course in writing better song lyrics. The song mainly consists of one line sung over and over. One line. Not even a good line. The Sex Pistols might not have been able to rhyme, but even they managed to crank out more than one line per song. “I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend” is as maudlin as songs come, and if it weren’t for the guitars, listeners wouldn’t be able to tell that this is supposed to be a band that spearheaded the punk rock movement.
Though there are some themes discussed on The Ramones’ self-titled that other artists wouldn’t touch with a million-foot pole, such as prostitution, (“I Don’t Wanna Walk Around With You”), The Ramones songwriting strategy is simple– think of a line, possibly two, and repeat ad nauseum. Then do it again with the next two-minute song. The only way I can tell that the song has changed is if the one line has changed, while the instrumentation of each song remains the same.
While The Ramones did go on to inspire countless other bands, punk rock or not, I have a hard time believing that this is the album that gave bored teenagers everywhere the vision to follow that musical path. It lacked the intensity, fury, and fun of other punk albums of that time, and even of future releases by The Ramones. It sounds tired before the band even managed to garner some recognition. Lyrically and musically, this album alone would not have been enough for me to continue listening to punk rock. Personally, I find this album to be lacking in energy, and without energy, punk rock would never have become the raucous force it is today.
Discover more from Dying Scene
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.